Best Waterproof Eyeliner
Golf is known to bring out the best in those who enjoy the game. Getting a hole in one can give anyone a confidence boost and improve their overall mood. It would make sense that during such a game you would want to put your best self forward. For some people that includes adding a touch of makeup here or there. But one thing that can definitely crumble the excellent mood is having your eyeliner run and smudge off your eyes, leaving the once lovely makeup looking messy. As frustrating as that can be, there is a solution to it. Thankfully waterproof eyeliner is here to take care of all of those issues. On this list, you will find the perfect eye makeup to keep you looking just as good in the country club as you do on the course.
In a Hurry? The test winner after 40 hrs of research
- WingLiner by Lovior
- COVERGIRL Perfect Blend Pencil
- Stila Stay All Day Pen
- Docolor Super Slim Pen
- Rimmel Exaggerate Definer Pencil
- Urban Decay Glide On
- Maybelline Eyestudio Gel
- L'Oréal Paris Infallible Never Fail
- Maybelline Unstoppable Eyeliner
- Esqido Gel Pencil
- Criteria Used for Evaluation
- Frequently Asked Questions
Top 10 Picks
1. WingLiner by Lovior
Cap can be difficult to remove
There can be a lot of issues that come with using this type of makeup. Not only can smudging and runny streaks cause problems, but not being able to do intricate designs like sharp flicked wings can also deter anyone from feeling like their best self. When you only have a limited amount of time before you go to enjoy a game of golf, there will not always be time to get just the right look. That is where this product comes to save the day. The versatile pen/stamp makeup delivers fast and accurate application every time. Plus it is smudge and waterproof. Whether you are going for a bold wing or a soft line across the lids, this product can do it all.Read more
Dual Ends and Double Pens
This makeup makes applying any type of eye makeup foolproof. Even those with the shakiest hands can apply a perfect wing It comes with two conveniently labeled double-sided pens for the left and right lid. Each pen has a wing stamp for its respective side plus a fine point felt tip and thicker sides. After the stamp is placed on the outer corner, the fine point pens can be used to connect the wing to the rest of the line, clear to the inner corner. This allows for the line and wing to smoothly flow together to create an effortless and sophisticated look.
Different Looks For All Needs
Not all lids come in one universal size, so neither do the wing options for this product. It is available in three sizes that will compliment any look. There is a petite 8mm stamp for more subtle and softer wings, a medium 10 mm stamp for a charming and bolder look, or larger 12 mm stamp for a gorgeous statement look. On days when you want a more toned down look, the pen side can add a touch of definition with a little swipe across the lids. The style options with this duo pen are limitless.
Cost and Value
With this product, you are not just purchasing a basic makeup tool. It will save you time and money. With the stamp, you can get the perfect look in one try. Less product will be wasted and you will be on your way quicker. Plus you are not just getting one pen, you are getting two. When it comes to makeup, this product comes with a very reasonable price. It will give you dozens of beautiful looks at a lower cost.
2. COVERGIRL Perfect Blend Pencil
Can be soft or defined
Fits easily in hand
Easy to sharpen
Does not come with a sharpener
Creamy, pigmented, and easy to use are always the perfect qualities to have in any makeup item. This pencil delivers smooth true color that is easily blended and long lasting. It is amazing for a smoky or natural look and very easy to use. No matter what look you are going for you can achieve it with this powerful pencil.Read more
Safe for Waterline and Lid
One great advantage of this pencil is that it doesn’t have to be limited to just the lid. It can apply solid, even color anywhere on the face. Unlike liquid liner, it is safe to apply to the waterline for a more dramatic look. It will stay as strong and pigmented in the waterline as it does on dry skin, which is a hard quality to find in a product like this. As an added bonus it can also be used on the eyebrows as a filler.
Sponge Tip Blends Out Color
To add character and gradient to any look, the pencil includes a sponge tip on the end for different styles. The sponge creates mess free blending wherever you want to smudge out your line. It can also be smudged out in the corner of the lid for a more defined look. The sponge works perfectly with the smooth formula of the pencil for effortless blending.
Cost and Value
This brand is well known and has been trusted by makeup users for years. This product delivers amazing color with each application and can quickly become an everyday staple in your makeup routine. The pigmented product stays locked in place all day for a solid look no matter what the occasion. Despite these advantages, the cost is low and very budget friendly.
3. Stila Stay All Day Pen
Good for eye corners
Not for waterline
Pens are quickly becoming the go-to product for makeup lovers everywhere. This pen is one of the most popular and considered to be one of the best. It was designed to be easy to use and create beautiful looks every time. It does not skip when it glides across the lid, making mess free and beautiful wings. On top of all of that, it is known for the long lasting staying power it has. Even in the hot sun, or drizzling rain this pen will stay in place through it all.Read more
Thin Tip for Clean Looks
When looking into pens, one of the biggest factors is the tip. Certain sizes and shapes have an effect on the outcome of the makeup and can be difficult to use. With this pen's thin and pointed structure it allows for precise lines and multiple different line sizes. Because it is so slim, it is less likely to smudge and cause mistakes, making it great for beginners.
Deep Intense Color
One of the biggest downfalls of any makeup product is the pigmentation. The color can come off opaque and require going over it a few times to get any color. Or it could quickly get a watery look once to product begins to run out. With this pen you get true, pigmented color that is good until the very last drop. With one simple swipe, you get a line of rich color that will last all day, even in the worst humidity.
Cost and value
This brand is known as one of the most quality driven brands today. Every one of their makeup pieces is made to deliver high end, pigmented results. Because of this, the cost may seem higher, but it is actually a mid-range price when purchasing such a high-quality makeup product. It will last all day and look as good as it did when it was first applied. Many customers do not mind the price because of the amazing quality.
4. Docolor Super Slim Pen
Thin enough for pockets
Good for dry lids
Not verified as cruelty-free
This pen is here to give the best a pen has to offer. The small pen allows for sharp and defined strokes that deposit excellent color. The handy felt tip applicator is just the right size to create thin, detailed lines while still being thick enough to make bold looks as well. Whether you prefer subtle or dramatic looks, this pen will help you get the perfect look.Read more
Soft Tip for Sensitive Lids
Although pens are regarded as one of the most frequently used products, they too have their faults. One of the worst things a pen can have is a tip that is too rough on the skin. Lids are especially sensitive because of how thin the skin on them is. A tip that is too hard can cause tiny cuts on the delicate skin and leave the area irritated for days. This felt tip pen is soft to the touch and can be swiped over the same area multiple times without causing any harm. It keeps the lids looking good and feeling good.
Body Allows for FreeHand Range
One of the most difficult parts of using any type of eye makeup is getting a steady line. What makes it so difficult is hand placement. Lids are relatively small areas to be working on, so the hands need to have as much ease of movement as possible. The design of this pen fits nicely in all hands, similar to an actual pen, and allows the user to have comfortable movement around the face.
Cost and Value
This pen has been compared to other high-end makeup brands and has proven to work amazingly. It makes applying the makeup easy and stress-free. The product glides on and stays solid. The cost is considered very low, especially for such a nice product. It has its own following of loyal customers who love the cost and the product.
5. Rimmel Exaggerate Definer Pencil
Includes a smudge tool
Good on any skin type
Can be difficult to remove
Imagine a pencil that looks like liquid liner on the lids and glides on smoother than gel. That is what you get with this universal pencil. It has the best qualities of other formulas in a convenient pencil form. One swipe will give an astounding color that will last all day, even in the worst conditions.Read more
Self Sharpening Saves Product
There are many benefits when using a twist-up pencil. Of course, there will no longer be the need to waste time trying to hunt down a manual sharpener, but that is not the only great thing about a self-sharpening pencil. When you use a hand sharpener you end up shaving off a considerable amount of product to make the pencil usable again. Self sharpeners do not waste any product by simply pushing the pencil up farther. This handy method will save both time and money.
Stays in Waterline
The waterline can be one of the trickiest parts of makeup. For those who enjoy a more prominent look, applying color to the waterline can be an essential step. However, due to the moisture, the color tends to separate and move, causing a patchy look. This pencil locks onto the waterline to make sure the highly pigmented color stays in place all day and will not smudge under the lash line. It stays exactly where you want it until you decide to take it off.
Cost and Value
Such a unique and handy product like this is not always easy to come across. Its versatility makes it great for any type of look. Not only does it last throughout the day, but it will also last through several uses. A product with this many benefits would usually be pricey, but that is not the case. The pencil is very affordable which makes it easy to purchase multiple at once so you can stock up on the incredible product.
6. Urban Decay Glide On
Easy to sharpen
Can be applied with a brush
Won’t smear eyeshadow
Must be manually sharpened
Smooth and long-lasting are the absolute best qualities in a pencil but do not always come together. With this pencil, it goes on as smooth as butter and can be smudged and blended for a smokey look. But it quickly dries down for all-day wear that remains soft on the lid. Many have used this for years and swear by this pencil.Read more
Long Lasting and not Irritating
The award-winning formula of this pencil is what makes it so special. It applies velvety- soft but dries down within 30 seconds that stays put for up to 12 hours. Despite the long-lasting abilities, it remains soft and smooth on the skin. This is due to its special mix of Vitamin E, cottonseed oil, and jojoba oil.
No Heavy or Tight Feeling
When a pencil puts down as much color as this, it is usually accompanied by an uncomfortable heavy feeling. Although it has vibrant color it skips on the thickness that others have. Also, it does not have the tight, pulling type of feeling that is common in long-wear makeup with quick drying time.
Cost and Value
This brand has spent years building its credibility and reputation as one of the leading makeup brands. Every one of their products is set to high expectations. True to the brand's ways, this pencil remains one of the best. It proves to be powerful, with brilliant color payoff and will last through whatever you need it to. With all this in mind, it makes sense that the price point for this pencil falls higher than others. However, if an intense long lasting color is what you are looking for then this is the perfect pencil.
7. Maybelline Eyestudio Gel
Comes with brush
Allergy, dermatologist, and Ophthalmologist tested
Safe for contact lenses
Difficult removal Without makeup remover
If liquid liners and pencils are not your thing, gel is another great option. This gel, in particular, has been one of the most popular gel liners for the last few years. It was specially formulated to last up to 24 hours and add amazing pops of color to any look. It is the miracle product for many customers due to the easy application and intense hold.Read more
This formula tossed aside the oils when making this intensely pigmented gel. Without oil, it makes it more beneficial than its competitors. For example, oil free is the best option for those wearing false lashes or eyelash extension, and that also makes it healthier for the skin. This will also be the ideal formula for those with sensitive eyes.
Safe for multiple uses
Many people are skeptical about putting anything in their waterline. Some do not even feel comfortable using a pencil. However, this gel is safe for both the lid and the waterline. Not only can the gel last longer than certain pencils, but it is also less likely to cause irritation and nicks. The cream like texture will smoothly glide onto any place it is applied, whereas a pencil may need a more firm hand.
Cost and Value
This rich colored gel has become the only liner product certain customers use. It meets every need with unreal performance. A similar product can come with a hefty price. However, this gel is incredibly budget friendly. The gel will last many uses and give consistent pleasing results. To many, this is the go-to liner because of how high end it seems despite the low cost.
8. L'Oréal Paris Infallible Never Fail
Can break if the liner is pushed up too far
This pencil was made to glide on smooth and be whatever you need it to be. If you need a more intense color it can easily be applied to the lid and waterline. If you need a subtle and softer look, a small amount blended out adds just the right touch of color. This can quickly become anyone's trusted liner pencil.Read more
Sharpener and Smudger
This pencil has everything it needs built right in. It is a mechanical pencil, so it does not actually require a hand sharpener. But it does have a sharpener built in for making the tip extra fine. The finely sharpened tip is amazing for making precise swipes. For a different type of look, it includes a smudging tool. This pencil can create any look desired with its assortment of tools and abilities.
Glides on Seamlessly
This formula has been praised for how smoothly it glides on by many customers. With similar products that have high pigmentation and long wear abilities customers often experience a dry feeling. However, this pencil has a smooth finish and only requires a slight touch to see color pay off.
Cost and Value
When buying this pencil, customers are going to get a high standard pencil that is long lasting and highly pigmented. Any product with such great quality could easily come with a very high price tag. However, the cost of this pencil falls at a very low midrange point. You will be getting all the amazing qualities of a high-end pencil at a fraction of the price.
9. Maybelline Unstoppable Eyeliner
Safe for the whole face
Easy remove cap
Can dry out without the cap
The name says it all. This pencil was formulated to offer vivid long-lasting color. With the very popular mechanical style pencil, it can be used within seconds and stays put all day. It is the perfect pencil for those in a hurry. Plus, it can be easily tossed in a bag for on the go use.Read more
Stays on, but Easily Removed
With long lasting pencils, they can often require vigorous scrubbing to be removed. Such harsh rubbing t the thin and sensitive optic area can cause tearing and irritation that can sometimes last for days. This formula is long-lasting and waterproof but can slip right off with a little makeup remover. You will get the long-lasting color without the severe scrubbing.
Great for beginners
Entering the world of liners can often be difficult and intimidating. This pencil allows for controlled, precise movements which helps create the exact line or shape you are trying to create. It also does not take much pressure to apply so you can focus on perfecting your lines. If you mess up or would like to start over it can be easily removed for a fresh clean start.
Cost and Value
This pencil has promised to keep your makeup in place all day and keep it looking fresh. It has been a staple product for years and has kept steady popularity. One pencil can last through dozens of uses, so there is no need for frequent restocking. One of the best parts of this pencil is its low price. Thanks to this product, a beautiful liner at a small cost is always an option.
10. Esqido Gel Pencil
Can be fragmented if dropped
Gel has been a favorite among makeup users for years. Now with is this product you get all the benefits of gel in a convenient pencil. There will be no more need to find and clean brushes to apply a sleek gel look anymore. The sturdy pencil applies even colored swipes every time to create the perfect look.Read more
Good for Mature Eyes
As we age, our faces can go through changes, and this includes the lids. With more mature skin it can be difficult to get a straight and precise look. However, this gel pencil is creamy and pigmented enough that it effortlessly glides across textured skin. As the eyelids get older, they become more sensitive. Excessive tugging and hard pressure can cause damage but may seem like the only way to get any color from the product. Because of the intense pigmentation, there is no need for much pressure or going over the same area repeatedly to get a good color pay off. It makes makeup simple and fun for anyone.
Sensitive Safe Formula
This gel was made without unnecessary chemicals and extra harmful ingredients. It is free of latex and other chemicals like sulfates, formaldehyde, or parabens. This makes it a great choice for someone with sensitive skin. The special formula is also vegan-friendly. This gel pencil can really be great for anyone to use.
Cost and Value
A lot of thought was put into this unique formula. The inclusive pencil can be used by a wide range of customers. The gel was made with high-quality products and makes it easy to apply makeup regardless of your skill level. The price range falls at a midpoint range but is not unreasonably priced. This pencil can deliver a smooth, fun makeup experience that will leave you happy and ready to use time after time.
Criteria Used for Evaluation
These makeup products should not be limite to one look.
There is no standard makeup look that every single makeup wearer must go by. In some cases, the look you want today may not be the one you want tomorrow. These makeup products must be able to compliment any style, from natural to bold. These items can do just that. They can be used to create elongated wings or just a light shading wherever you want. The best product will be one that can be used for any occasion and on a daily basis. No matter how often your look may change, these products will adapt to all your styles. All of the products also come in a variety of colors, hues, and finishes for all your makeup needs.
You should never have to worry about runny makeup.
When you are out in the sun playing sports the last thing you want is to end up with raccoon eyes. The outdoors can sometimes be unpredictable, and unexpected rain or humidity can ruin your makeup. However, you can be prepared with these long-lasting waterproof products. They stay in place throughout the day, whether rain or shine. You can go right to lunch from the course and look as fresh as you did in the morning.
The amount of different liner types seems endless
When it comes to this type of makeup there are lots of different formulas so that everyone can find their perfect match. Not every person will enjoy the same type of product, so there were many different ones included on this list. From gel to liquid, there is sure to be something for everyone.
Makeup should never feel uncomfortable.
When wearing makeup, it can sometimes leave an uncomfortable feeling. There can be heaviness, stickiness, tightness, and tons of other unwanted feelings that could discourage people from using makeup. The products listed here have shown to be lightweight and easy to wear. The less you can feel the makeup on your face the better experience you will have while wearing it.
Regardless of what type of look you want, it is best to start from the inner corner. This allows for the look to appear more blended and seamless. The thinnest point should fall in the very corner of the eye and progressively get thicker the closer it gets to the outer corner. Or, for a subtle look it can remain the same thickness throughout the lid, but use a smudger tool to add a blended out look to the outermost corner.
The eye area is one of the most sensitive areas on the body. If it gets a scrape the scrape can quickly become infected or irritated. If there is damage to the area applying any makeup product can cause further damage. Additionally, if there is an infection in the area you want to apply makeup, the makeup could be contaminated and should be discarded so the infection does not recur.
Frequently Asked Questions
q: What liner is safe for water lines?
Waterlines can be a very fun option to add a pop of color to any look. However not every product is safe to apply to the sensitive area. Formulas that are generally safe for this area include gel, pencil, and Kohl. Liquid should never be applied to the waterline. The more powdery or liquidy a product makes it a bad option for the waterline. However softer, creamy products work great. It should be noted that no matter what product is used if irritation occurs use of the product should be stopped immediately.
q: Are these easy to apply?
Applying this type of makeup can sometimes be challenging. Although getting it to be the perfect shape on the first try may take some time, these products glide on with ease with the first swipe. The gels and pencils have smooth, creamy formulas that will go on even with a light touch. The liquids are velvety and fluid and flow onto the lid like a silky paint. No matter your experience level or the formula you choose, these products will be easy to slide onto wherever you want them.
q: What type is best for beginners?
The first time using this type of makeup can sometimes seem intimidating. Although all of these products are user-friendly, some are more easily used by a more skilled and experienced hand. For first time users, the best options would be gels and pencils. These can be better controlled and are more forgiving to errors. It is best to avoid liquids at first because these are a very fluid product that can be frustrating during the first few uses. However, it does not take much practice to master all types of liners.
q: What color is best?
Color is more of a personal preference choice. While some may prefer more natural beige tones, others may enjoy a more vibrant color such as purple. There are some colors that are considered basic staple colors, however. For example, black can be used on a daily basis as either a subtle or dramatic accent. It also compliments most eye colors and can appear almost natural if used correctly. Another common option is brown. The color is a bit softer and can appear very soft and natural if black is too dark. This is also very complimentary of blue eyes. If you are looking for a color to bring out the natural colors of your eyes, you should aim for a color opposite of yours on the color wheel. So for example, if you have a green color, the red hues would make them pop.
q: Are these okay for sensitive eyes?
Dealing with sensitive eyes can be difficult, especially with makeup. While applying makeup to the upper lid should not be an issue, it can be difficult to put near or in the waterline. However, if you have sensitive eyes and still wish to use makeup in these areas, there are some that will work. Hypoallergenic formulas are available, and water resistant ones will work to keep from running if your eyes tend to water. Gels and creamy formula pencils will work the best, Dry or hard product should be avoided.
q: Are all products cruelty-free?
The short answer is no, not every product is cruelty-free. The easiest way to tell if one is would be to look on the package. If the product is cruelty-free it will usually be displayed somewhere on the product where it would be easy to see. Some countries require animal testing for all skin related products, so be sure to look for the stamp on any products you purchase if animal testing is something you would like to avoid.